Second National Preventive Health Research Programme     Defined Terms - Bohemian Teenager Symphony Orchestra Programme    Bohemian Teenager Symphony Orchestras Programme

Three Famous Orchestras And Choirs Which Have Successfully Targeted Homeless and Marginalised means:

(a)        Latin American country of Venezuela has delivered, over the last 34 years The National Youth Orchestra System, colloquially known as El Sistema, successfully steering more than a million kids, many from slum areas, away from a life of drugs/crime, into the world of classical music, and conducted orchestral performances at esteemed concert halls which include the BBC Proms and The Lincoln Centre The fundamental tenet of El Sistema is not musical, but social.  The ABC documentary series Foreign Correspondent telecast Bravo! Encore! on 30 June 2009.

(b)        ABC production Choir of Hard Knocks, based on Sydney Street Choir of circa 2001, which drew upon the musical talents of Jonathon Welch to assemble a choir in Melbourne which morphed into the Melbourne Street Choir, Inc.

(c)        Montreal's Accueil Bonneau Homeless choir which won accolades and hearts from its diverse repertoire from 'The Mamas and the Papas' California Dreamin' to Beethoven's "Ode to Joy" -- not just in Quebec but across Canada and worldwide -

  • recording six albums over a 6 year tenure,

  • performing more than 1,000 live concerts in cities as far away as Paris,

  • eventually disbanded due to the members elevating their orchestral skills and QOL.

The fact that the Montreal's Accueil Bonneau Homeless choir ultimately disbanded "due to the members elevating their orchestral skills and QOL" is patent testimony to the scope of the BTSO SPV to deliver its Five Functions to achieve the Four Purposes of the Second National Preventive Health Programme whilst maintain an Orchestra Performance Focus.

 

The below explains other countries which have adopted the Venezuela Model notes in (a) above:

 

A BBC TV documentary programme in the Imagine arts series, first shown on 18 Nov 2008, examined the history and ethos of the Venezuela Model and its role in tackling the social problems of Venezuela and its success in transforming the lives of some of the nation's poorest children, including interviews with Gustavo Dudamel, key members of the orchestra, and current and former students.  Hosted by Alan Yentob, the film took a detailed look at the unique music education system of Venezuela, of which the orchestra is an integral part, and described the recent attempt to imitate its success in a deprived part of Scotland. 

 

Below are extracts from the article "Sistema Scotland Adopts Venezuelan Musical Miracle" which explain the programme, Big Noise, delivered by the organisation Sistema Scotland. 

The fundamental principle of El Sistema, which is that the main aims of Big Noise are not musical, but social.  “We use the orchestra as an engine for social change,” “If we produce great musicians then that will be great, but it’s not our principle purpose.  Existing children’s and youth orchestras do a great job producing excellent musicians.  We are not seeking to replace any of those or make them Sistema orchestras.  But we hope that the children we work with – children who would not previously have joined existing youth orchestras – will now do so after coming to music through Sistema.”  Furthermore, Sistema-inspired orchestras can work in more than one type of social circumstance.  “Wherever you go in the world, there will be communities suffering from feelings of exclusion, which lead to poor health, crime and substance abuse.  It might take some adapting to local circumstances, but we think a Sistema-like orchestra could play a big part in bringing about generational change in areas like that anywhere.  We could look at Sistema as being the regeneration that goes on inside people’s head, in order to match the regeneration that has gone on in the streets.”

The initial Big Noise youth orchestra is in Raploch, a community that is “comparatively at the bottom of the economic scale in Scotland,” ranked in 2004 as “one of the top 5% of areas of multiple deprivations in Scotland.”  The average income in Raploch is £6,240, and 22% of the community experiences incidents of the ‘Big 3’ (coronary heart disease, stroke and cancer).  “In our program,” says Killean, “over 50% of the children who attended the Summer School in 2008 came from families who were or had been involved with social services.”  Comparatively, deprivation in Scotland ranks nowhere near that found in Venezuela.  “Absolute poverty is worse in Venezuela where people live in shanty towns, may well have difficulty finding enough to eat, and where we know of children who have been shot on the way to orchestra practice.  Scotland is a typical post-industrial society, and while there is general prosperity, many urban areas suffer from depravation, crime, substance abuse, and poor health.” 

Generated by the instructors at Big Noise, the repertoire played by the children is primarily based upon fun songs and games.  As Killean explains, “the curriculum is progressive, so in nursery you may learn a song, walk it, sing it, clap it, and in Primary 1 you may also use this song, but progress in how you work with it.  Then, in the after-school programme, you will be learning how to play this song on the instruments.  All of the repertoire we use is pitched appropriately for both the children’s voices, and for beginning work on the open strings.”

With a budget provided by the Scottish Arts Council as well as numerous private donations, Big Noise hopes to start up orchestra centres in Glasgow and Aberdeen by 2013, bringing the total of Big Noise centres to three.  A good deal of support and inspiration has come from FESNOJIV (National System of Youth and Children Orchestras of Venezuela), who in their thirty-plus years of experience have demonstrated the value of orchestras as “engines for social change.”  Big Noise is in fact the UK representative for FESNOJIV.  Killean adds that they have “supported us with a good deal of information, and hosted visits where the organizers of Sistema Scotland and our musicians have been able to see and learn from El Sistema in action.  We are very proud that they have officially accepted us into the Sistema family.”  Further support has come from the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, and BBC Scotland, which is currently working on a documentary about the efforts being done at Big Noise.

See also “North American Counterparts:  El Sistema Inspires Projects in Ottawa & New York,”